Dirtiest player in the premier league this season?

[JoeJoeJoeJoe]

Ric Flair

 

[Orion]

Yeah ok, Steven Gerrard is a dirtier player than Fellaini...

I'd argue they're comparable.

 

[Whitechapel]

Fellaini, absolute shithouse. A dirty tackle is one thing (oi oi) but to intentionally try and injure another player is just disgusting.

He gets away with so much though because he's so tall and clumsy, and the fact refs do tend to turn a blind eye to general United shithousery. (except our FA Cup game at Old Trafford)

 

[PUSBCCFC]

As much as I love him, Shawcross should be in the top 5.

 

[SALTIRE]

I'd argue they're comparable.

There's probably dozens as bad if not worse by Fellaini since his time in the league - I'm not defending Gerrard, but Fellaini is just a battering ram and a dirty one at that.

 

[G-Dragon]

I'd argue they're comparable.

 

[thespus]

As much as I love him, Shawcross should be in the top 5.

"Not that kind of player. Ramsey should be the one apologizing. c*** didn't even text Ryan back."

 

[johnnytodd]

 

[johnnytodd]

 

[Stevencc]

No one is denying Fellaini is a dirty bastard, do you agree that Gerrard was always pretty handy with his elbows?

 

[BlueBee]

Why is diego costa on this. He's hardly dirty...He winds players (and the fans) up. The Skrtel incidents were 'dirty' (they were at each other all game so it was fair game) but I can't think of anything else.

We'd all miss him if he left the prem.

 

[johnnytodd]

Fellaini is taller than most and his elbows are at head height for most too.

 

[G-Dragon]

No one is denying Fellaini is a dirty bastard, do you agree that Gerrard was always pretty handy with his elbows?

I agree. But Orion seems to deny fellaini is. Apparently he never intentionally elbows someone.

 

[PUSBCCFC]

"Not that kind of player. Ramsey should be the one apologizing. c*** didn't even text Ryan back."

I don't think he wanted to break his leg..

 

[Orion]

I agree. But Orion seems to deny fellaini is. Apparently he never intentionally elbows someone.

I didn't say never, I said he's got better this season. I'm not oblivious to some of the stuff he's pulled in the past. I was defending him against this big palava about the McShane tackle and how far it's been blown out of proportion.

And with Gerrard, I was just making a point. People acting like his shit don't stink.

 

[G-Dragon]

I didn't say never, I said he's got better this season. I'm not oblivious to some of the stuff he's pulled in the past. I was defending him against this big palava about the McShane tackle and how far it's been blown out of proportion.

And with Gerrard, I was just making a point. People acting like his shit don't stink.

No one has.

 

[SALTIRE]

Why is diego costa on this. He's hardly dirty...He winds players (and the fans) up. The Skrtel incidents were 'dirty' (they were at each other all game so it was fair game) but I can't think of anything else.

We'd all miss him if he left the prem.

Stamping on two players in the same game this season? Come on now, as much as I like Costa, he is a brute at times.

 

[BlueBee]

Stamping on two players in the same game this season? Come on now, as much as I like Costa, he is a brute at times.

You love him really.

 

[AFCB_Mark]

We've got a central midfielder, Harry Arter, who picks up a booking most games. To call him Aggressive and gobby doesn't do him justice. So I look forward to seeing what the PL makes of him.

 

[Stocky]

This is all one big witch hunt from Silkyman. Fellaini has never committed a foul in his life.

 

[SALTIRE]

You love him really.

Aye he is great tbh, have always said so, especially when he was winding up old Jose and Pepe in the Madrid derbies. I like players with a bit of bite about them, Suarez is the same.

 

[Liu Tiffany]

wonderful player

 

[Skinner]

Another thread of United vs Liverpool

YAY

 

[Shank]

If it's shirt grabbing then it's Shawcross. If it's out and out dirty it's Cattermole. Although sometimes I just think he is stupid rather than dirty

I don't think Cattermole is dirty, he's just slow for that level so seems to always come in a bit late.

Fellaini, Gerrard, Diego Costa, Rooney i'd class as dirty. Fellaini most of all, Crouch was large and never threw arms/elbows out like Fellaini has done over the years.

 

[Jarv]

For me it's either Brad Guzan or Joe Hart

they're both pretty dirty in those pictures

There were rumours David Beckham was pretty dirty in the bedroom too. (kids ask your parents)

 

[Luke1995]

Cattermole?

Has he been dirty tho he just has that name of being dirty now