Jockney
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2015
- Messages
- 2,969
- Reaction score
- 1,552
- Points
- 113
- Supports
- Fred Onyedinma
Halfway through A People's History of the United States, by Howard Zinn.
A potted history of the United States (a little over five centuries covered by only six hundred pages), from Columbus to Dubya. Zinn gives primacy to the experiences of the colonised and the oppressed, which is what drew me to this potted history instead of the countless others. The problem is, I'm reading it straight off the back of CLR James's detailed account of the San Domingo slave revolt/Haitian independence, which admittedly had a narrower focus but equally draws mainly upon primary sources from French archives and had a genuinely fresh analytical frame (Liberty, Equality, Fraternity as a larger Atlantic question). APHotUS has a broader purview but it doesn't feel particularly coherent, mainly because every period is presented as being fairly discrete; part of a larger genesis of the nation only in terms of theme and system, but without really connecting strongly what was happening in the Americas with what was happening elsewhere.
A potted history of the United States (a little over five centuries covered by only six hundred pages), from Columbus to Dubya. Zinn gives primacy to the experiences of the colonised and the oppressed, which is what drew me to this potted history instead of the countless others. The problem is, I'm reading it straight off the back of CLR James's detailed account of the San Domingo slave revolt/Haitian independence, which admittedly had a narrower focus but equally draws mainly upon primary sources from French archives and had a genuinely fresh analytical frame (Liberty, Equality, Fraternity as a larger Atlantic question). APHotUS has a broader purview but it doesn't feel particularly coherent, mainly because every period is presented as being fairly discrete; part of a larger genesis of the nation only in terms of theme and system, but without really connecting strongly what was happening in the Americas with what was happening elsewhere.