Night of the Werewolves - The Legend of Black Shuck

[HarvSFC]

I think people preferred to execute someone who had behaved suspiciously, rather than someone who was voted for as a joke.

As mentioned, Krazy8 was innocent. I would have thought the wolves would have preferred to have kept on an innocent that was acting suspicously, rather than an innocent that was being voted for as a joke. However when the voting is between a wolf and an innocent it's obvious what side they'll take.

 

[This Charming Mike]

MagpieBee's obsession with outing members of the Circle of Trust concerns me. Revealing more members would leave them susceptible to being sought and killed by the wolves. I have complete faith in the CoT to steer us through this tough, tough time and I think he should too.

MagpieBee for execution

 

[MagpieBee]

MagpieBee's obsession with outing members of the Circle of Trust concerns me. Revealing more members would leave them susceptible to being sought and killed by the wolves. I have complete faith in the CoT to steer us through this tough, tough time and I think he should too.

MagpieBee for execution

I wouldn't call it an obsession, but I do think it would be the right thing to do. Understand that suggesting it puts me in the firing line, but you'll just be killing an innocent!

 

[IanH]

I think Last request's nomination of me is fair enough if he feels I've done something suspicious. He's leading the village well so far. I'm not sure twice voting near the deadline is that suspicious myself though, - being a non circle-of-trust villager doesn't come with too many knowledge privileges, so I was waiting see how things played out.

I have questioned a few peoples' seeming reluctance to get involved in this thread as much as they do other parts of the forum (Cardsfan, Aberstone, TCH) and they all gave reasons, so it's not like I've been afraid of calling people out, even if I've not started the voting for anyone yet.

 

[last request]

This is where my gameplan has come in, as an innocent. The bandwagon for Cardsfan started, I was waiting it out to see the results. The results being that a group then decided to vote to kill off the innocent Krazy8. What made certain people jump on the Krazy8, who later turned out to be an innocent bandwagon, rather than the Cardsfan one?

Although you were suspicious of Cardsfan yourself yesterday. Now with the call outs to people that have voted for him, it looks like he may have joined the CoT, so I'm not sure who to vote for this round.

Do you think Stags fan was doing the same thing?

The Cardsfan vote wagon on the day Krazy was executed.:

Stags4Life (then voted Krazy8)
Joe
Spire (then unvoted, then voted Krazy8)
Harv
Mr Elmos (then unvoted, then voted Krazy8)
Mike (then voted Krazy8)
Jon ((then voted Krazy8)
Krazy8
JJH (then unvoted)
MagPieBee
IanH

The Krazy 8 vote wagon:

Stringy
TechnoGypsy
Yellow
Tom
LR
Cardsfan
Mr. Elmo
Cider
Magic
Stags
Jon

Harv, based on your plan, who on these lists do you think is most likely to be a wolf?

Have to consider that Stags voted Cards before the pigeon letter arrived as well.

Toffee_Joe Why the change of heart from voting Mr Elmo to Etty Abrics. Do you think the latter is now an easier innocent execution to get through after seeing a couple of other town members voting Etty?

 

[HarvSFC]

Do you think Stags fan was doing the same thing?

The Cardsfan vote wagon on the day Krazy was executed.:

Stags4Life (then voted Krazy8)
Joe
Spire (then unvoted, then voted Krazy8)
Harv
Mr Elmos (then unvoted, then voted Krazy8)
Mike (then voted Krazy8)
Jon ((then voted Krazy8)
Krazy8
JJH (then unvoted)
MagPieBee
IanH

The Krazy 8 vote wagon:

Stringy
TechnoGypsy
Yellow
Tom
LR
Cardsfan
Mr. Elmo
Cider
Magic
Stags
Jon

Harv, based on your plan, who on these lists do you think is most likely to be a wolf?

Have to consider that Stags voted Cards before the pigeon letter arrived as well.

Toffee_Joe Why the change of heart from voting Mr Elmo to Etty Abrics. Do you think the latter is now an easier innocent execution to get through after seeing a couple of other town members voting Etty?

Well I don't know who's in the CoT, or not. However JJH's decision there is quite questionable and his attempts to execute Ciderhead, who was later innocent. What's the thought process on voting and then unvoting?

"My wolf chum looks likely to die with the most votes, so I'll vote for him, so it makes me look innocent."

Later

"Ah, crap, it's close now. Better unvote and not vote for the innocent guy either."

 

[Techno Natch]

I'm going to vote for Yellow. I know he's my son and it hurts me to do it. The fact remains though that he was up to something when the wolves came and he'd only just got back from London when they turned up. He might very well be one and has floated throughout the game without doing much.

 

[SALTIRE]

I'm backing the mayor here, as said, he's been leading us well thus far.

IanH for execution.

 

[Techno Natch]

Except for when he wanted to kill you

 

[SALTIRE]

Except for when he wanted to kill you

No one is infallible mate, I forgive him that!

 

[JJH]

The COT has a new member.

I'm going to vote IanH for execution.

Somebody I suspected earlier on in the game, and still suspect. Always seems to want to vote as inconspicuously as possible. A late voter on the Cardsfan wagon the day Krazy8 was executed. A late voter on the Ravenbish wagon yesterday.

Also suspicious of JJH for similar reasons.

StagsForLife and Harv - it's getting a bit suspicious that you keep on voting Cardsfan. Particularly when so many people end up voting for a wolf in RavenBish and you don't. I understand it's part of a prank but that is exactly the type of thing Wolves like to take advantage of.

Also - there are currently 8 alive members of the COT. Just to show why I don't need to reveal anyone else who is in it, and scupper any plans the Wolves might have of setting up a fake one.

I've made one vote out of turn, other than that I've just followed with the majority or voted with your decision.

 

[JoeJoeJoeJoe]

IanH for execution

 

[IanH]

MagpieBee for execution

 

[Aberstone]

I'd get the seer to investigate IanH tomorrow, there is nothing for me to suspect that he is a wolf but I'd like to know the outcome before voting. Chances are I'll be voting between JJ and Etty Abrics, the armourer and boatman haven't been seen since the wolves entered our village.

 

[yellow]

Yeah, which would be an incredibly stupid thing for a wolf to do... happy to be investigated if people feel the need.

And yeah, it would be difficult for the Wolves to pull off, but why take the risk in opening up the opportunity for them?

Hmm, it's a different tactic, but I'm afraid I still have some doubts.

MagpieBee for execution.

 

[yellow]

I'm going to vote for Yellow. I know he's my son and it hurts me to do it. The fact remains though that he was up to something when the wolves came and he'd only just got back from London when they turned up. He might very well be one and has floated throughout the game without doing much.

& I thought we were family…

I told you I was away purely for work duty, nothing more and nothing less. It's been incredibly difficult trying to bring cheer to this village in this horrible, horrible time, so much so that I have rejected an offer from a nearby circus to stay and continue the fight against these nasty creatures.

 

[Magic]

Toffee_Joe for execution. Hunch.

 

[JonBCFC]

MagpieBee for execution

The constant trying to get the CoT to reveal members even when several good reasons to not do so is suspicious for me.

 

[Toffee_Joe]

Toffee_Joe for execution. Hunch.

If I were a wolf I would be following the crowd a lot more with my votes rather than drawing attention to myself. You are entitled to your opinion though even if it is wrong.

 

[Aberstone]

StagsForLife for execution.

Last request makes a few good points above about SFL voting for executions before the pigeon arrived with the letter, plus it was well documented that the stranger went to the barbers and he was the first innocent to be killed.

 

[HarvSFC]

IanH for execution

 

[Mr Elmo]

MagpieBee for execution

Just something about the way he wants to get CoT members revealed when we don't need to. Sadly their isn't anyone too suspicious at the moment but I feel we have to go with him right now as he seems the most likely.

 

[JJH]

No idea who to vote for - will decide by 9, but don't have strong suspicions on anyone currently.

 

[SUTSS]

Deadline is 9pm tonight but I'm not going to be around. Execution and Wolfy stuff will be put up once I've got back.

 

[blade1889]

This round is really hard, dont thinK MagpieBee would be daft enough to try and out some CoT members as a wolf. Unless it was a double bluff that appears to be backfiring.

IanH I just don't think theres much on either, at least not any more than there is in on a number of people.

I still have some suspicions on TCM, still find it weird that he doesn't post much and his only reply to me mentioning it was just to vote for me in retaliation. But no one else seems bothered by him at the moment.

LR makes some good points on StagForLife although I'm still not sure theres much. But as I have to vote for some StagsForLife for execution

 

[This Charming Mike]

I'm not a wolf mate. You have my word.

 

[HarvSFC]

This round is really hard, dont thinK MagpieBee would be daft enough to try and out some CoT members as a wolf. Unless it was a double bluff that appears to be backfiring.

IanH I just don't think theres much on either, at least not any more than there is in on a number of people.

I still have some suspicions on TCM, still find it weird that he doesn't post much and his only reply to me mentioning it was just to vote for me in retaliation. But no one else seems bothered by him at the moment.

LR makes some good points on StagForLife although I'm still not sure theres much. But as I have to vote for some StagsForLife for execution

A suspicious thing about Mike, is that SUTSS made a mistake and killed him in the OP. Marking him as a dead wolf.

 

[JJH]

A suspicious thing about Mike, is that SUTSS made a mistake and killed him in the OP. Marking him as a dead wolf.

When was this?

 

[blade1889]

A suspicious thing about Mike, is that SUTSS made a mistake and killed him in the OP. Marking him as a dead wolf.

When was this?

Completely forgot about that! Think it was yesterday!?

 

[HarvSFC]

Is that an error from SUTSS on the OP, I thought we only knew the identity of the two dead wolves (Steady and Ravenbish), yet there's now a 3rd dead wolf?

Mike isn't dead, is he? It have I missed something..

You are of course right. No idea why he was marked as dead wolf. I don't remember doing it but I must have made a mistake at some point.